About Our Agency

Outside of Phelan Insurance Agency''''s Versailles Office

Founded in 1949, Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc. has consistently been a leader in providing quality protection for hundreds of individuals, families and businesses. Offering superior customer service and reputable low rates, along with our ability to understand our customers' coverage needs, has driven the success of our agency for over 70 years.

Starting as a new Agency in the small town of Versailles, Ohio, Bernard W. Phelan founded Phelan Insurance Agency as a way to serve locals with their personal insurance. Utilizing his background as an independent claims adjuster, B.W. Phelan was able to expand into the business insurance market as well. After being taken over by his son, James (Jim) Phelan, the agency was able to grow its customer base to all of Western Ohio. Phelan Insurance used technological  advances, enhanced customer service, and more specialized products to quickly become one of the most trusted insurance agencies in Ohio. 

After expanding our reach and product offerings, Phelan Insurance was able to expand even more by opening a second location in the Cincinnati-West Chester area in 2009. Since then, Phelan Insurance Agency has been able to serve clients across the US. Still family owned, operated, and run by Todd and Brent Phelan, our agency has the same mindset of the small agency we started out as. We value building positive relationships with our customers so they personally know and trust the agent handling their needs.

As an Independent Insurance Agency, we are able to search for the absolute best coverage at the best price for your needs from the trusted insurance companies we carry. We are competitive to make sure you get the best deal, without compromising quality.

Our Mission is to be a leading provider of quality insurance, risk management, and employee benefit solutions. We will accomplish this through innovative methods and personalized, superior service by professionals who care.

By offering world class protection for your auto, home, health, business, and life insurance, we make sure that you're covered today, as well as in the future, so that you can focus on what is important to you and your family. At Phelan Insurance, our job is to assist you in identifying your needs, while putting together a customized plan that's simple and easy to understand.

We take the mystery out of insurance and help you make sense of it, so you can look forward to a brighter, more secure future. To do this, we evaluate your specific needs to find the company that will give you the best value for your dollar, while supplying superior protection. The companies we represent offer tested, reliable insurance products and excellent customer service. We make sure the insurance companies we represent have an outstanding reputation for fast and fair claims service.


 View a comprehensive list of the insurance companies we carry under the Our Carriers page

Meet our team of agents and employees who make Phelan Insurance the amazing company it is today under the Our Team page.

Interesting in becoming a part of our team? View our job openings and how you can join our agency under the Career Opportunities page.

Learn more about how we give back to our community under the Our Community page.

Hear from our clients about their experiences with us on the Testimonials page.

We are confident you will benefit from our services and can take advantage of our experience in serving you for all your insurance needs. We encourage you to contact us at (800)843-3069 with any questions or concerns.

Copyright 2019 Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc. All Rights Reserved. For more information, feel free to | Contact Us   Terms of use  Privacy Statement