Make a payment on your insurance bill below

Click Here to Pay Your Bill With Check

Use the link above to set up a secure one-time or reocurring payment by providing your bank account and routing numbers.

Click Here to Pay Your Bill With Credit Card

Use the link above to pay online with your credit card. Note that a security & delivery fee applies to all credit card payments


Find your insurance provider below and use the links to view your billing information. 

Acuity Acuity Logo
All lines of business 1-800-242-7666 Payment site click here
Aetna Aetna Logo
All lines of business Payment site click here
Anthem Insurance Anthem Insurance Logo
All lines of business Payment site click here
Chubb Chubb Logo
All lines of business 1-800-372-4822 Payment site click here
CNA CNA Logo
All lines of business 800-869-0808
Donegal Insurance Group Donegal Insurance Group Logo
All lines of business 1-800-877-0600 Payment site click here
EMC Insurance Companies EMC Insurance Companies Logo
All lines of business multiple Payment site click here
Grange Insurance Grange Insurance Logo
All lines of business 1-877-468-3466 Payment site click here
Hagerty Insurance Hagerty Insurance Logo
All lines of business Payment site click here
Liberty Mutual Liberty Mutual Logo
All lines of business 1-800-526-1547 Payment site click here
Medical Mutual of Ohio Medical Mutual of Ohio Logo
All lines of business 216/687-7000 Payment site click here
MetLife MetLife Logo
All lines of business 1-800-680-3354 Payment site click here
Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Logo
All lines of business 1-866-680-5508 Payment site click here
Progressive Progressive Logo
All lines of business 1-800-876-5581 Payment site click here
Safeco Safeco Logo
All lines of business 1-877-566-6001 Payment site click here
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies The Cincinnati Insurance Companies Logo
All lines of business 1-513-870-2000 Payment site click here
The Harford Insurance The Harford Insurance Logo
All lines of business 1-855-590-2456 Payment site click here
Travelers Travelers Logo
All lines of business 1-800-550-7716 Payment site click here
United Health Care United Health Care Logo
All lines of business multiple Payment site click here
Utica National Insurance Group Utica National Insurance Group Logo
All lines of business 1-800-274-1914 Payment site click here
Westfield Insurance Westfield Insurance Logo
All lines of business 1-800-766-9133 Payment site click here

Copyright 2019 Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc. All Rights Reserved. For more information, feel free to | Contact Us   Terms of use  Privacy Statement