Report a Claim

Reporting a claim can be a long, confusing process. We're here to make it easier by providing you direct links to report a claim through our carriers. Use the links below to complete your claim, visit our Customer Tools center to file a claim through our customer portals, or give us a call at (800)843-3069 for more help.


Acuity Acuity
All lines of business 1-800-242-7666 Claim site click here
Chubb Chubb
All lines of business 1-800-252-4670 Claim site click here
CNA CNA
All lines of business (1-877-262-2727) Claim site click here
Donegal Insurance Group Donegal Insurance Group
All lines of business 1-800-877-0600 Claim site click here
EMC Insurance Companies EMC Insurance Companies
All lines of business 888-362-2255
Grange Insurance Grange Insurance
All lines of business 1-877-468-3466
Liberty Mutual Liberty Mutual
All lines of business 1-800-2CLAIMS Claim site click here
Medical Mutual of Ohio Medical Mutual of Ohio
All lines of business 216/687-7000 Claim site click here
MetLife MetLife
All lines of business 1-800-854-6011 Claim site click here
Ohio Mutual Insurance Group Ohio Mutual Insurance Group
All lines of business 1-888-895-7725 Claim site click here
Progressive Progressive
All lines of business 1-800-274-4499 Claim site click here
Safeco Safeco
All lines of business 1-800-332-3226 Claim site click here
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies The Cincinnati Insurance Companies
All lines of business 1-877-242-2544 Claim site click here
The Harford Insurance The Harford Insurance
All lines of business 1-877-445-5826 Claim site click here
Travelers Travelers
All lines of business 1-800-claim33 Claim site click here
United Health Care United Health Care
All lines of business multiple
Utica National Insurance Group Utica National Insurance Group
All lines of business 1-800-216-1420 Claim site click here
Westfield Insurance Westfield Insurance
All lines of business 1-866-937-2663 Claim site click here

Copyright 2019 Phelan Insurance Agency, Inc. All Rights Reserved. For more information, feel free to | Contact Us   Terms of use  Privacy Statement